For an 18-year time horizon, the maths overwhelmingly favours Stocks and Shares.
A Cash JISA pays interest at typically 3% to 4.5% (May 2026 rates). Over 18 years, £100/month compounded at 4% grows to roughly £31,400 - about £21,400 of contributions plus £10,000 of interest. Decent but not transformational.
A Stocks and Shares JISA invested in a global equity tracker has historically returned around 7% nominal (5% real after inflation). The same £100/month over 18 years at 7% grows to roughly £43,300 - about £21,400 of contributions plus £21,900 of investment growth. That's £12,000 more than the Cash JISA on the same monthly contribution.
The behavioural objection - 'but equities are risky' - is real for short horizons but vanishes at 18 years. The longest period in modern UK and US history where a globally-diversified equity portfolio underperformed cash over 18 years is... none of them. The same is not true at 5 years, 10 years, or even 15 years. But at 18, the equity premium is the dominant signal in the data.
The one case for Cash JISA: grandparents or family members who want certainty more than they want optimal returns, and who'd be unhappy seeing the value temporarily drop during a market crash. Their feelings count too. Cash JISA is the right answer for them - just understand the trade-off.
Our
Cash ISA comparison covers Cash JISA-equivalent rates from the main UK savings providers, but the JISA-specific market is narrower.